An old school classic, lemon meringue tarts and pies are velvety, tart, yet sweet, and oh so delicious. These mini lemon meringue pies make the perfect dessert for a spring brunch or other special occasion. While the traditional lemon meringue pie is no more complicated than the recipe I will share today, my variation keeps all the different parts separate right until you want to assemble and serve the tarts. This makes the lemon meringue tarts easy to prepare ahead of time, and require almost no baking!
The meringue is usually what keeps people from making this classic dessert, and is very similar to making a pavlova. I will walk you through all the steps, resulting in a fool proof professional looking tart for you to serve to your friends and family.
This post contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated if a purchase is made through the links provided. For more information please read my affiliate disclosure.
Before Starting These Lemon Meringue Tarts
Before starting this recipe, there are a few pieces of kitchen equipment you may want to double check are in your cupboard. Because the lemon meringue tarts are ‘no-bake’ you will need a mini blow torch or a broiler to caramelize the tops of the meringue after assembling. You’ll also want to make sure you have little tart molds or a muffin tin in which you can blind bake the tart crusts.
Finally, I would highly suggest using an electric stand mixer and a sugar thermometer to make your Swiss meringues. you can find more details on that below. Happy Baking! -Chef Markus Mueller
Start With The Crust
As with any pie or tart, you will need to make a pie dough. I would suggest making this classic pie dough recipe from scratch, it can easily be made the night before in just five minutes. You could always buy a pre-made tart shell though if you wanted. BUT it will always taste better if you make it yourself, guaranteed!
Take the pie dough and roll it out until it is about 5 millimetres thick. With your tart mold (also called tart pans) trace circles on the dough cutting out as many circles as you have tart pans. When it comes to tart pans I would highly recommend buying a set of professional loose base tart pans.(affiliate link). They are well worth the investment, especially since they are one of the cheaper pieces of kitchen equipment you can buy. They are more durable, the removable base helps prevent stuck tart shells, and if taken care of properly, will last you a lifetime. The perfect addition to any budding chefs or bakers tool kit!
Roll out the circles of dough until they are roughly twice the size of the tart molds. Place the dough into the buttered tart molds, making sure to keep a quarter of an inch above the rim of the mold. This excess dough will slightly shrink while the tart base bakes. Cut out a small square of parchment paper and place this on top of the dough in the mold.
Weigh the tart dough with pie weights, or lacking those you can substitute dry beans, lentils, or rice. The weight is placed in the tart shells when blind baking to prevent the base of the dough from bubbling up. Halfway through the baking you will need to remove the parchment and weights to allow the base and sides to properly brown.
Pre-heat your oven to 400F and then place your weighted tart shells in the fridge to chill.
The colder the dough is before you bake it the less shrinkage you will have in the end product. You may also freeze the raw tarts to bake at a later date. – Chef Markus Mueller
Once cold, bake the tart shells in the oven for 8-10 minutes until the edges slightly start to brown. Remove the parchment and weights and continue to bake the tarts for 5-8 minutes until they are light golden all over. Remove from the oven and cool on a wire rack in the tart pans until you can remove the shells with your hands. Set these aside while you make your lemon curd and Swiss meringue.
Next …The Lemon Curd
Lemon curd is simply a lemon flavored egg custard that is cooked, cooled, and then spooned into the blind baked tart shells. This prevents us from having to bake these little lemon meringue tarts.
To make the lemon curd you will need:
- 3/4 cups of fresh squeezed lemon juice
- 1 cup of sugar
- 6 egg yolks
- 1 tablespoon of cold butter – cubed
Mix the lemon juice, sugar, and egg yolks in a small sauce pot and stir until everything is well combined. Slowly heat this mixture in the pot until it starts to slightly thicken. It should barely coat a spoon and drip off in a thick ribbon. Add your cubed butter to this thickened curd and stir in until it is completely melted.
The butter will add a nice gloss to the lemon curd and give it a richer taste. It will also take a bit of the tang off of the lemon. Cool the lemon curd in the fridge, keeping in mind that it will continue to thicken as it cools.
Finally, The Meringue
For this recipe, I decided to use Swiss meringue instead of common French or Italian meringue. Swiss meringue is best used as a topping or as an icing which is meant to be eaten right away and needs no further cooking. The eggs are cooked to 160F (unlike in French meringue which uses raw egg whites) as the egg white are beaten in the bowl.
French meringues are usually used when the product is baked afterwards such as in a pavlova, macrons, or the traditional lemon meringue pie which is baked in the oven like a regular pie.
Meringue is essentially a combination of egg whites mixed with sugar which then has air whipped into it. The sugar helps stabilize the small air bubbles that are created by whipping the egg whites, creating a fluffy light product. The more sugar you add, the glossier and denser the meringue will become. As a rule of thumb, you want almost twice as much sugar as egg whites by weight.
Since meringues need to be whipped for an extended period of time to incorporate enough air and get the whites to thicken, I highly recommend using an electric stand mixer. While I realize that these are often quite expensive, if you do plan on buying one I would suggest a KitchenAid Stand Mixer (affiliate link).
Every so often they do go on sale and you can get them at a good price. As a professional Chef, I can attest to its quality and I am lucky enough to say that I own one personally, and use it quite frequently to cook, and even bake my own homemade sandwich bread in it!
Other brands simply do not do as good of a job long term and do not offer the same amount of attachments as a KitchenAid does. Regardless of what mixer you end up using, you need to whip the egg whites and sugar until it forms a fluffy mixture that will form little peaks and “stand up” on its own.
For this Swiss meringue, measure out:
- 165 grams of egg whites ( 5 egg whites)
- 250 grams of sugar
- 1tsp of vanilla extract
Put all the ingredients in your mixing bowl. Heat a pot of water on the stove until it is just barely simmering, and stir the egg mixture over this hot water to slowly pasteurize the eggs. Traditionally Swiss meringue is only cooked to 104F (40C) but in order to pasteurize the egg whites and make them safer to eat, I will cook them to 160F (71C).
Stir the eggs the entire time to make sure they do not curdle and turn to scrambled eggs. The sugar that is mixed in should help prevent this and the whole thing should turn into a soupy sticky liquid. Once the egg mixture reached the desired temperature, place the bowl on your mixture and with a whip attachment whip the egg whites on medium-high, until they are light, glossy and have cooled.
The end result should hold nice firm peaks on its own and have almost a marshmallow like consistency.
Once you have all your components finished you can assemble the tarts right away or pack everything up separately to take with you if you are serving these at a location other than your home. Once assembled slightly torch the meringue with a broiler or blow torch for a nice browned effect. Garnish the tarts with a little lemon zest and you are all ready to go!
Lemon Meringue Tarts
Pie Crust for the Tart Shells
- 1 x 9" pie dough recipe for tart shells
- 3/4 cup lemon juiced
- 1 cup sugar
- 6 egg yolks
- 1 Tbsp cold butter
- 5 egg whites 165 grams
- 250 grams sugar
- 3 drops vanilla extract
For The Tart Shells
- Roll out the pie dough to about 5 millimeters thick. Cut out circles with your tart pan, and then roll out the the tart until it is roughly twice the size of the mold and 2-3 millimeters thick.
- Place the rolled out dough in greased tart pans, leaving a little excess to allow for shrinkage. Weight the dough with parchment paper and pie weights then chill until the tart dough is cold.
- Bake in a pre-heated 400F oven for 8-10 minutes. Remove the pie weights and continue baking for another 5-8 minutes or until the shells are golden brown all over.
- Mix the fresh squeezed lemon juice, 1 cup of sugar and egg yolks in a sauce pot.
- Whisk together until combined and then STIR the pot until the mixture begins to thicken over medium heat. Stir in the 1 Tbsp of cold butter.
- Cover and refrigerate.
- Start a double boiler on the stove.
- Mix the 5 egg whites and 250 grams of sugar with the vanilla extract in a bowl. Over the double boiler stir this egg mixture carefully until the temperature reaches 160F to pasteurize the eggs.
- Take the bowl of the double boiler and either with a stand mixer or by hand whip the meringue mixture until cool and stiff peaks form. The texture should be similar to marshmellows.
Assemble The lemon Meringue Tarts
- Assemble the lemon meringue tarts by spooning the chilled lemon curd into the cooled tart shells. Top with the Swiss meringue and lightly brulee the top with a mini blow torch or broiler. Garnish with a curl of lemon zest.